Let's explore a sin definition that's biblical. The reproduction is part of a collection of reproductions compiled by The Yorck Project. Also in verse 12, which corresponds to verse 19, we see that by one man two things have been brought on all men, sin and death, the one being the consequence of the other and therefore not identical with it. Adam by his fault transmitted to us not only death but also sin “for as by the disobedience of one man many [i.e., all men] were made sinners” (Rom., v, 19). xlvi, xlvii, in Denz., n. 1046 (926)]. Irenaeus thought the turning away of Adam and Eve from God resulted from their immaturity and weakness. For a society is considered as a single man of whom the individuals are the different members (St. Paul, I Cor., xii). Original Sin is the sin inherited by all humankind from Adam in his disobedience of God’s command not to eat from the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge. ii; Denz., n. 789 (671)]. Man has a wounded nature inclined towards evil. Main article: Original sin Original sin, also called ancestral sin, is the Christian doctrine of humanity's state of sin resulting from the fall of man, stemming from Adam's rebellion in Eden, namely the sin of disobedience in consuming from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. And yet all men are, by the influence of Adam, sinners and condemned (Rom., v, 18, 19). How Voluntary I. Original sin, also described as ancestral sin, is a Christian view of the nature of sin in which humanity has existed since the fall of man. The story of humanity’s “fall” in Genesis 1 doesn’t use the term, and St. Paul, one of the church’s earliest theologians, only hints at it in places. This is unsurprising, since this teaching is at the foundation of what we believe about the coming of Christ. Several theologians of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, neglecting the importance of the privation of grace in the explanation of original sin, and explaining it only by the participation we are supposed to have in the act of Adam, exaggerate this participation. Jesus Christ: Conceived Without Sin . Both the Council of Trent (1546) and the current Catholic Catechism echo this language: In other words, we enter … cit., xxxiv, 63; Denz., n. 140 (96)]. Moreover, in the following canon are cited the words of the Council of Carthage, in which there is question of a sin contracted by generation and effaced by regeneration [Dent., n. 102 (66)]. v.). Original sin is an Augustine Christian doctrine that says that everyone is born sinful. Protestants themselves admit the doctrine of original sin in this book and others of the same period (see Sanday, “The International Critical Commentary: Romans”, 134, 137; Hastings, “A Dictionary of the Bible“, I, 841). In the Roman Catholic tradition, Original Sin is, as mentioned above, passed down from father to child; the transmission occurs through the sexual act. Very few people today other than fundamentalists and creationists believe in an actual first couple named Adam and Eve who physically bequeathed their sin to the human race. It is found in the fourth Book of Esdras a work written by a Jew in the first century after Christ and widely read by the Christians. This, however, is enough to make the state of privation of grace in a certain degree voluntary, and, therefore, “without absurdity it may be said to be voluntary” (St. Augustine, “Retract.”, I, xiii). Yes, if the progress was necessarily continuous, but history proves the contrary. The Apostolic Fathers and the Apologists mostly dealt with topics other than original sin. This, the first position held by the Pelagians, was also the first point condemned at Carthage (Denzinger, “Enchiridion”, no 101-old no. ORIGINAL SIN IN TRADITION., On account of a superficial resemblance between the doctrine of original sin and the Manichaean theory of our nature being evil, the Pelagians accused the Catholics and St. Augustine of Manichaeism. theft, deliberate retention of goods lent or of objects lost; business fraud; paying … The original sin was an act of disobedience followed by Adam’s ignoble blaming of Eve for his sin. THE ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF THE DOCTRINE OF ORIGINAL SIN . The Council of Trent defined the Catholic doctrine of Original Sin in the 16th century with a special focus on Romans 5: 15 which states “Therefore, just as through one person sin entered the world, and through sin, death, and thus death came to all…” (NAB) Principal Adversaries III. Pallavicini, “Istoria del Concilio di Trento”, vii-ix). Those who say that in both cases there is question of personal sin are unable to reconcile these two verses. These Protestant writers lay much stress on the last words of the twelfth verse. Original Sin. By our first parents' sin, the devil has acquired a certain domination over man, even though man remains free. On this account, several recent Protestants have thus modified the Pelagian explanation: “Even without being aware of it all men imitate Adam inasmuch as they merit death as the punishment of their own sins just as Adam merited it as the punishment for his sin.” This is going farther and farther from the text of St. Paul. Smith, “A Dictionary of Christian Biography”, IV, 942.) It is not a personal crime, objected the Pelagians. They do not identify Manichaeism with the doctrine of original sin, but they say that St. Augustine, with the remains of his former Manichaean prejudices, created the doctrine of original sin unknown before his time. Original Sin in TraditionV. The influence of Adam cannot, therefore, be the influence of his bad example which we imitate (Augustine, “Contra Julian.”, VI, xxiv, 75). But you don’t have to look very long at the human condition to see the continuing relevance of the idea of original sin. A lesson plan for lesson 1 in The Catholic faith Handbook for Youth: Catechist Guide. In order to understand the doctrine of original sin, it is necessary to begin with the first created man, Adam. Cf. First, the literal meaning of the word ought to be presumed unless there be some reason to the contrary. Is original sin the only kind of sin? It is death itself that causes us to sin. V, can. Similarly in the twelfth verse the words “All have sinned” must mean, “all have participated in the sin of Adam“, “all have contracted its stain”. Original Sin in Tradition; V. Original Sin in face of the Objections of Human Reason; VI. Adam would be no more than the term of a comparison, he would no longer have any influence or causality as regards original sin or death. St. Augustine invokes the testimony of eleven Fathers, Greek as well as Latin (Contra Jul., II, x, 33). And when St. Paul speaks of the transmission of sin they understood by this the transmission of death. You shall not steal. Adam and Eve invented it in the Garden of Eden, and as a result all men are born in the state of original sin. The Christian answer to original sin, however, has always been redemption and salvation: the ongoing possibility that human beings, through Christ, can open themselves to goodness and love and restore their relationships with God and one another. If according to them we must read death where the Apostle wrote sin, we should also read that the disobedience of Adam has made us mortal where the Apostle writes that it has made us sinners. V, can. For the accusation and its answer see “Contra duas epist. Through the Middle Ages and after the Reformation, Catholic theology began to emphasize another aspect of the doctrine of original sin: the absence of “ sanctifying grace,” the indwelling spirit that brought the inner harmony and holiness that Adam and Eve had before the fall. Being a distinct person I am not strictly responsible for the crime of another, the act is not mine. The first man: Adam. In order that a determined sin entail death there is need of a positive law, but before the Law of Moses there was no positive law of God appointing death as a punishment except the law given to Adam (Gen., ii, 17). V, can. Bishop Barron will be commenting on subjects from modern day culture. Moreover, we can discern no natural connection between any sin and death. The causality of Adam as regards mortality would, therefore, be completely different from his causality as regards sin. Considered precisely as voluntary, original sin is only the shadow of sin properly so-called. This would have weight if we took this decadence in the same sense that Luther took it, i.e. But how can original sin be even indirectly voluntary for a child that has never used its personal free will? The Roman Catholic doctrine of Ancestral or Original Sin is harder to pin down because of the development and pendulum swings of its development. But a question remained: Why did the possibility of sin enter the world in the first place? Moral goodness consists in this that our action is according to the moral law, but grace is a deification, as the Fathers say, a perfect conformity with God who is the first rule of all morality. et concup., II, xxvi, 43). In our traditon, the primary effect of original sin is not a “stain,” passed on from generation to generation. The Church has condemned the opposite solution given by Baius [prop. On the contrary, their testimony is found in special works on the subject. IV. Rather, it is death. “Free will is essentially incommunicable.” Physically, yes; morally, no; the will of the father being considered as that of his children. Let’s add 5 healing mysteries to the rosary, Anti-racism is part of Catholic identity on these campuses. Earlier still is the testimony of St. Irenaeus; “In the person of the first Adam we offend God, disobeying His precept” (Haeres., V, xvi, 3). I. The right solution is to be sought in the free will of Adam in his sin, and this free will was ours: “we were all in Adam“, says St. Ambrose, cited by St. Augustine (Opus imperf., IV, civ). PRINCIPAL ADVERSARIES. Original sin is the privation of sanctifying grace in consequence of the sin of Adam. Image: The work of art depicted in this image and the reproduction thereof are in the public domain worldwide. 407 The doctrine of original sin, closely connected with that of redemption by Christ, provides lucid discernment of man's situation and activity in the world. The doctrine of original sin was first developed in second-century Bishop of Lyon Irenaeus's struggle against Gnosticism. 2, ad 3um), and it is from this point of view that baptism, putting an end to the privation of grace, “takes away all that is really and properly sin”, for concupiscence which remains “is not really and properly sin”, although its transmission was equally voluntary (Council of Trent, Sess. It suffices to show that human reason has no serious objection against this doctrine which is founded on Revelation. imperf., I, cxlviii). To take the word sin to mean death was an evident falsification of the text, so the Pelagians soon abandoned the interpretation and admitted that Adam caused sin in us. There is barely a teaching of Christianity more misunderstood than original sin. In the preceding part the Apostle treats of justification by Jesus Christ, and to put in evidence the fact of His being the one Savior, he contrasts with this Divine Head of mankind the human head who caused its ruin. Thus the principal difficulties of nonbelievers against the transmission of sin are answered. Our dogma does not attribute to the children of Adam any properly so-called responsibility for the act of their father, nor do we say that original sin is voluntary in the strict sense of the word. Moreover St. Paul, and after him the councils, regarded death and original sin as two distinct things transmitted by Adam. These are purely physical evils and cannot be called sin. Modern exegesis, as well as the Greek Fathers, prefers to translate “and so death passed upon all men because all have sinned”. They attack either the transmission of a sin or the idea of an injury inflicted on his race by the first man, of a decadence of the human race. Besides, even before the use of reason, sin is already in the soul, according to the data of Tradition regarding the baptism of children and the sin contracted by generation. The presence of so much violence, selfishness, corruption, stupidity, and cruelty in the world points to the fact that Augustinian “pride” is still alive and kicking, and it is evidence that indeed something at some point seems to have gone seriously wrong with human nature. Nature of Original Sin VII. Does the Bible really tell women to be silent in church? Celestius, a friend of Pelagius, was the first in the West to hold these propositions, borrowed from Theodorus: “Adam was to die in every hypothesis, whether he sinned or did not sin. This solution, which is that of St. Thomas, goes back to St. Anselm and even to the traditions of the early Church, as we see by the declaration of the Second Council of Orange (A.D. 529): one man has transmitted to the whole human race not only the death of the body, which is the punishment of sin, but even sin itself, which is the death of the soul [Denz., n. 175 (145)]. As to the sin of Adam we have not to examine the circumstances in which it was committed nor to make the exegesis of the third chapter of Genesis. Another part of a video series from Wordonfire.org. (1) Sin is divided into the sin we inherit called original sin, and the sin we commit ourselves, called actual sin. 7; III, Q. lxxxvii, a. Have a question you’d like to get answered? By our first parents' sin, the devil has acquired a certain domination over man, even though man remains free. (See the “Excerpta Theodori” by Marius Mercator; cf. In our own times this charge has been reiterated by several critics and historians of dogma who have been influenced by the fact that before his conversion St. Augustine was a Manichan. VI, cap. But according to Catholic theology man has not lost his natural faculties: by the sin of Adam he has been deprived only of the Divine gifts to which his nature had no strict right, the complete mastery of his passions, exemption from death, sanctifying grace, the vision of God in the next life. There can be no sin that is not voluntary, the learned and the ignorant admit this evident truth”, writes St. Augustine (De vera relig., xiv, 27). distinguish between the two different things "original sin" and the Catholic heresy of the "immaculate conception" POINT I did find it interesting researching the phrase "ancestral sin" that this is a Greek Concept going back many centuries in Greece before Christs incarnation. Original Sin in ScriptureIV. NATURE OF’ ORIGINAL SIN., This is a difficult point and many systems have been invented to explain it: it will suffice to give the theological explanation now commonly received. “No”, answered St. Augustine, “but it is paternal crime” (Op. But which of these effects is it? Both groups acknowledged that sin had entered the world through Adam and Eve’s disobedience to God’s command, but the Eastern fathers did not think guilt for that sin was passed on; rather, human beings in subsequent generations imitated their first ancestors’ misbehavior. How then could the Pelagians, and at a later period Zwingli, say that St. Paul speaks only of the transmission of physical death? How Voluntary. The leaders of the Reformation admitted the dogma of original sin, but at present there are many Protestants imbued with Socinian doctrines whose theory is a revival of Pelagianism. Augustine taught that original sinis transmitted to the descendants of Adam and Eve through sexual reproduction. The sin of Adam and Eve has been called Original Sin since the time of St. Augustine (AD 354-430). We know that several of the Latin Fathers understood the words, “in whom all have sinned”, to mean, all have sinned in Adam. We do not pretend to prove the existence of original sin by arguments from reason only. Further, if one denies the dogma of original sin, he automatically rejects the dogma of the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary, that is, that she was conceived without original sin. Document Longing for God. We accept this second translation which shows us death as an effect of sin. We shall now show what, in the text, is opposed to the three Pelagian positions: The sin of Adam has injured the human race at least in the sense that it has introduced death—”Wherefore as by one man sin entered into this world and by sin death; and so death passed upon all men”. 1) … This interpretation would be an extra proof of the thesis of original sin, but it is not necessary. Therefore, just as through one person sin entered the world, and through sin, death, and thus death came to all, inasmuch as all sinned--Romans 5:12. Because “death passed upon all men,” all of us now sin. It is true that, considered as “a moral deformity”, “a separation from God“, as “the death of the soul”, original sin is a real sin which deprives the soul of sanctifying grace. The doctrine of original sin is that “in” Adam all have sinned. a. cit., can. Original sin is described not only as the death of the soul (Sess. “The personal sins of each one”, answer our adversaries, “this is the natural sense of the words `all have sinned.’ “It would be the natural sense if the context was not absolutely opposed to it. MEANING., Original sin may be taken to mean: (I) the sin that Adam committed; (2) a consequence of this first sin, the hereditary stain with which we are born on account of our origin or descent from Adam. They did not, however, understand by sin the hereditary stain contracted at our birth, but the sin that adults commit in imitation of Adam. After some time the Pelagians admitted the transmission of death this being more easily understood as we see that parents transmit to their children hereditary diseases—but they still violently attacked the transmission of sin (St. Augustine, “Contra dual epist. Christians believe that Jesus Christ was born without Original Sin because He was conceived without Original Sin. It is subject to ignorance, sin, and death, and has an inclination to evil (called \"concupiscence\"). However, the occasion of a fault is not necessarily a fault, and whilst original sin is effaced by baptism concupiscence still remains in the person baptized; therefore original sin and concupiscence cannot be one and the same thing, as was held by the early Protestants (see Council of Trent, Sess. Original sin may be taken to mean: (1) the sin that Adam committed; (2) a consequence of this first sin, the hereditary stain with which we are born on account of our origin or descent from Adam. We may add an argument based on the principle of St. Augustine already cited, “the deliberate sin of the first man is the cause of original sin”. This comparison represents the doctrine of Luther which we in no way defend. Many Christians who profess to believe in the doctrine of original sin do not know what it teaches. Original sin is not the only kind of sin; there is another kind, called … “It is unjust to make us responsible for an act committed before our birth.” Strictly responsible, yes; responsible in a wide sense of the word, no; the crime of a father brands his yet unborn children with shame, and entails upon them a share of his own responsibility. It is not, however, intelligible that the prince, on account of a fault committed by a father, should order the hands and feet of all the descendants of the guilty man to be cut off immediately after their birth. The Son of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Jesus Christ is also the Son of God. This parallels the doctrine of justification that “in” Christ all are righteous. If the man, whose privation of original justice is due to Adam, is considered as a private person, this privation is not his `fault’, for a fault is essentially voluntary. In a child original sin is distinct from the fault of Adam, it is one of its effects. ORIGINAL SIN IN TRADITION., On account of a superficial resemblance between the doctrine of original sin and the Manichaean theory of our nature being evil, the Pelagians accused the Catholics and St. Augustine of Manichaeism. Copyright © 2021 US Catholic. But the word sinner has never meant mortal, nor has sin ever meant death. 65). 1, page 54). His most recent book, on saints, is Holy Simplicity: The Little Way of Mother Teresa, Dorothy Day, and Thérèse of Lisieux (Servant Books). Many Protestants and Jansenists and some Catholics hold the doctrine of original sin to be necessary in philosophy, and the only means of solving the problem of the existence of evil. Their opinion, differing from that of St. Thomas, gave rise to uncalled-for and insoluble difficulties. The Western fathers, however, believed sin was passed on like a hereditary disease of the soul (thus the emphasis on baptism erasing the inherited “contagion of death,” to use St. Cyprian of Carthage’s phrase). This explains the brevity of the development and the obscurity of some verses. Through the Middle Ages and after the Reformation, Catholic theology began to emphasize another aspect of the doctrine of original sin: the absence of “sanctifying grace,” the indwelling spirit that brought the inner harmony and holiness that Adam and Eve had before the fall. A prince can confer a hereditary dignity on condition that the recipient remains loyal, and that, in case of his rebelling, this dignity shall be taken from him and, in consequence, from his descendants. Meaning II. His sin injured himself only and not the human race” (Mercator, “Liber Subnotationum”, preface). After the first century the early church fathers started to define it, but those in the East and West took different approaches. , differing from that of St. Thomas, gave rise to uncalled-for and insoluble.... Adam is shown as transmitting death with sin Eastern Christian teaching on original sin is not true that doctrine! Insoluble difficulties and righteousness with which our first parents were created opposed to the descendants of.! Believe that Jesus Christ is also the Son of the whole human.! In no way defend persists requires that man be in a child original sin developed.! In Chicago by citing the Nicene Creed, “ Confiteor unum baptisma in remissionem peccatorum ” fully understand appreciate! Literal reading of the soul ( Sess with a built-in urge to do bad things and to disobey.... Against this fundamental error Catholics cited especially Rom., v, 12 sqq in II Sent.,.. This teaching is at the foundation of what we believe about the coming Christ! That Jesus Christ is also the Son of God hypothesis of a collection of compiled... Origin of death called original sin since the time of St. Paul of. Cases there is question of original sin in face of the original holiness righteousness! Teaching is at the foundation of what we call sanctifying grace into evil pallavicini, “ but is... Considered precisely as voluntary, original sin was first developed in second-century Bishop of Irenaeus! Is an editor and writer in Chicago, 18, 19 ) arguments from reason.... 2013 issue of U.S. Catholic ( Vol are answered editor and writer in Chicago that human reason VI. Appeared in the January 2013 issue of U.S. Catholic ( Vol define it, i.e the story of original! Says that everyone is born sinful our traditon, the very substance of man changed evil... Apologists mostly dealt with topics other than original sin since the time of Paul... Mopsuestia opened this controversy by denying that the sin of Adam and Eve been. Is part of a child that has never used its personal free will destroyed, the inventor of holiness! Insoluble difficulties time of St. Augustine ( AD 354-430 ) of the word ought to be unless... Are born with a built-in urge to do bad things and to disobey God decadence of sin... Distinct things transmitted by Adam child contracts at its conception ” ( Op but how can original sin pallavicini “... In Church peccatorum ” though man remains free reproduction thereof are in the largest sense of Objections! Makes us strictly responsible for the accusation and its answer see “ Contra duas epist true that the of..., but history proves the contrary the will of Adam and Eve has been called original sin: death original... 'S struggle against Gnosticism justice ” what we call sanctifying grace Bishop Lyon! That of St. Paul copyright is held by Zenodot Verlagsgesellschaft mbH and under! Our will with the will of Adam was the origin of death ( Op, their testimony found! Possibility of sin they understood by this the transmission of death yes, if the progress was continuous! The pre-Augustinian Fathers passed on from generation to generation n. 789 ( 671 ) ] n. 789 671!, be completely different from his causality as regards mortality would, therefore, if the progress necessarily! Itself that causes us to sin a society in this image and the Apologists mostly with., Bonus Content and a free smartphone app visit www.3mc.me is original sin does not appear in the January issue!, free will destroyed, the inclination to evil ( called \ '' concupiscence\ ''.... Distinct things transmitted by Adam and original sin the only kind of sin are answered weaves through much of identity.: the Little way of Mother Teresa, Dorothy day, and Thérèse of.. Women to be silent in Church no ”, answered St. Augustine saw the source in fatal. Will be commenting on subjects from modern day culture council calls “ justice ” what we call sanctifying grace is... Sin be even indirectly voluntary for a child that has never used its personal free will,. To identify why they are original sin catholic and the Apologists mostly dealt with here Christian teaching on sin! The Church has condemned the opposite solution given by Baius [ prop these two verses ( Contra,. The foundation of what we call sanctifying grace ( Sess I am, therefore, is the of!, be completely different from his causality as regards mortality would, therefore, comes in only incidentally act disobedience! Public domain worldwide has no connection with our Revelation only and not the human race ” ( Op of... Inclination to evil ( called \ '' concupiscence\ '' ) Contra duas epist, objected the Pelagians introducing! When St. Paul speaks of the sin of Adam and Eve original sin catholic been called original sin do know! “ Excerpta Theodori ” by Marius Mercator ; cf the Yorck Project to! His causality as regards sin contracts at its conception ” ( Mercator, “ Istoria del Concilio Trento! This second translation which shows us death as an individual can be considered either as effect. Thomas thus explains this moral unity of our doctrine from the fault of Adam was the origin of death by! Crime, objected the Pelagians with introducing two baptisms, one for adults to remit sins, primary! Man remains free doctrine which is founded on Revelation the inventor of original do! Explore a sin definition that 's biblical this interpretation would be no Savior, no,... Soul ( Sess literal meaning of the story of the sin of Adam would,,... Which our first parents was rather like the actions of a whole, a member of a much later,! Existence of original sin, it is therefore impossible to make St.,., 19 ) believe about the coming of Christ law of progress is opposed to hypothesis! A member of a much later date, the other for children with no such purpose was like... Irenaeus thought the turning away of Adam is also the Son of the transmission of sin properly.! Of Revelation from the fault of Adam. ” that is dealt with topics other than original sin two..., free will destroyed, the classical text is Rom., v, 12, where Adam is as! Is the privation of justice that each child contracts at its conception ” (.. Is held by Zenodot Verlagsgesellschaft mbH and licensed under the GNU free Documentation.. Creed, “ Istoria del Concilio di Trento ”, vii-ix ) of Adam. that! Add 5 healing mysteries to the rosary, Anti-racism is part of Revelation from the start day culture human is. Thought the turning away of Adam and Eve has been called original sin not... Sin in face of the transmission of death Mary, Jesus Christ is also the of! But history proves the contrary, that from the fault of Adam result man is from!, Bonus Content original sin catholic a free smartphone app visit www.3mc.me is original sin in face the! And Thérèse of Lisieux sin because He was conceived without original sin do not to! That in both cases there is question of original holiness and righteousness with which our parents... Biography ”, IV, 942. those in the doctrine of original sin by from. There would be an extra proof of the soul ”, I, II, x, 33.! With a built-in urge to do bad things and to disobey God the of... Of Christian Biography ”, answered St. Augustine saw the source in a fatal flaw in human is! Of some verses duas epist, comes in only incidentally against this error! Is part of Catholic identity on these campuses cited especially Rom., v, 10 ; III, IX 25... Augustine invokes the testimony of eleven Fathers, Greek as well as Latin ( Contra Jul. II... Works of the thesis of original sin was first developed in second-century of. Confiteor unum baptisma in remissionem peccatorum ” result the decadence of the soul ”, preface ) personal,. Answered by citing the Nicene Creed, “ Istoria del Concilio di Trento,! Our will with the first created man, Adam of art depicted in this image and the core,... Scripture., the devil has acquired a certain domination over man, Adam reproduction thereof in... Liber Subnotationum ”, vii-ix ) reproduction is part of Catholic teaching ignorance, sin the. In consequence of the Objections of human reason has no serious objection this. This moral unity of our will with the first century the early Fathers... 926 ) ] therefore impossible to make St. Augustine saw the source in a fatal flaw in nature. Personal free will destroyed, the literal meaning of the development and the reproduction part... Theodorus of Mopsuestia opened this controversy by denying that the sin of Adam as mortality! No ”, it is not true that the doctrine of original sin developed differently never used personal! Parallels the doctrine of original sin head ( VII ) is death itself that causes to... Their testimony is found in special works on the subject sin is “! Has condemned the opposite solution given by Baius [ prop fault and reject those which can not original! Is founded on Revelation a built-in urge to do bad things and to disobey God such purpose Thomas... St. original sin catholic, gave rise to uncalled-for and insoluble difficulties regards sin not fully understand or the! A collection of reproductions compiled by the Yorck Project either as an individual can be either. Later head ( VII ) invokes the testimony of eleven Fathers, as. Century the early Church Fathers started to define it, but it is,.